asked Sep 15 '17 at 09:57 by muelb (111)

10
3

Is there any change in the midi mute behaviour of Bitwig? I need to have all midi messages muted when I mute a track. There are Situations in my Workflow, when I do not send audio of a Hardware track to Bitwig before I send it out to my speakers. So please add a possibility (checkbox per track) If mute affects also midi and not only audio.

I will not change to Version 2 until this feature is implemented, cannot understand if it's not possible!

Every DAW I have used in 15+ years of doing this stuff can mute midi in the sequencer, it's such a standard behavior. I really don't understand why Bitwig wants to force you to route audio from your hardware back into it, and then mute the audio. That's not necessarily everybody's workflow! There should at least be an option to choose if mutes affect midi and/or audio!

Any update on this? Many users are holding back on switching to Bitwig because of this.

link

answered Oct 02 '17 at 14:32 by Errortrax (41)

edited Oct 02 '17 at 14:34

Fully agree +1! it's a bread and butter feature that's still missing in this DAW

link

answered Feb 11 at 21:55 by Schwedter (21)

edited Feb 11 at 21:57

I totally agree with the need of a global track muting including MIDI HW instrument : it is SO standard !! When I mute a track with my controller, I indeed expect that it mutes the signal sent to the external synth. In my case, many of my synths play in the external mixer directly and not back in BW.

One solution without changing the whole audio nature of all BW tracks would be to be able to trig each enable/disable buttons of all instruments included in the device panel with the main mute button of the track.

We do love BW but this is a HUGE limitation in any usual (ananlogous) workflow.. Please do something for this, thanks !

link

answered Nov 25 '17 at 14:09 by yomguy (31)

+1 also when bouncing a plugin-track my synths turn crazy and I have to switch them off and on. thats annoying.

link

answered Jan 07 at 17:22 by muteme (11)

+1 vote on this, if it counts... It seems the developers not eager to fix this problem or at least answer something:-(

link

answered Jan 14 at 18:34 by Petroff (74)

I want to record a midi track on external hardware. Record the Audio. Then Mute the Midi, so I can then record a different sound using the same hardware synth. Having to mute the Device is an painful and unintuitive design.

link

answered Feb 04 at 21:57 by kevinpwilson (11)

New Bitwig studio user here, just learning the ropes, but discovered this behavior over the weekend and was surprised like all the other posters here... I just filed a support request for this feature.

I see this topic also discussed on a kvraudio forum thread going back to 2015. What transpires from this old thread (my interpretation) is this is the result of a design choice that Bitwig finds difficult to change, either because of product architecture/philosophy or because it would be difficult to address without compromising other functionality.

It is however easy to see why this design choice is a problem. It suffices to accept the fact that many (perhaps most?) multitimbral MIDI instruments do not have separate audio outputs per MIDI part/channel. Therefore the only way to mute some MIDI channels and not others is to stop playing them. Same story with a drum machine that (typically) plays kick, snare, claps and hi-hat all off of note events on e.g. channel 10: to mute only the snare, one has to be able to stop sending snare notes, but continue sending the others.

Looking for workarounds in the interim, I gather that one can deactivate the unwanted MIDI track(s) (Alt-A by default). However this obviously doesn't work well at all for the solo function. Anyone knows of another/better workaround?

link

answered Feb 06 at 02:08 by jfgallant (11)

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or __italic__
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Tags:

×226
×13

Asked: Sep 15 '17 at 09:57

Seen: 892 times

Last updated: Feb 11 at 21:57